Have you wondered if a certain dataset can be used for OSM? What does it mean for a license to be “compatible” with OSM and ODbL? This talk will give pointers on where to look for information, common compatibility issues, and best practices for presenting a license to LWG for help review.
Have you wondered if a certain dataset can be used for OSM? What does it mean for a license to be “compatible” with OSM and ODbL? This talk will give pointers on where to look for information, common compatibility issues, and best practices for presenting a license to LWG for help review.
Outline: Sources of information about the license
Website (page from which data is downloaded, about page, FAQ, TOS)
Accompanying file (e.g., README, LICENSE)
Terms, credits, etc.
Metadata Information about licenses/dataset previously evaluated for use with OSM
Imports wiki page
License compatibility page
forums/lists US data
Federal data and the public domain
State data
Local data Common compatibility issues
Attribution
Use restrictions (e.g., noncommercial/personal/research)
Privacy
Sharealike
Revocability
Indemnity
Local laws
Things that are usually not a problem (disclaimer of warranty/accuracy, trademarks, governing law, ) Making it easy for others to read a license
Link everything!
Include all information about the source
Where to obtain
Description of where/who the data is from
Include all information about the license
What the license is
Any info about permitted uses
Any prior OSM discussion
Flag common compatibility issues and why you think they are or are not issues
Quote the relevant sections of the license (include the section number!)
Explain your reasoning
If the license references other laws/regulations/terms, look them up and link to and quote from them. |