The early ideals of openness and decentralization have given way to a reality in which a handful of companies exert disproportionate control over the digital ecosystem and exploit its resources for their own gain. In this era, the concept of openness presents a paradox - it both challenges and enables the concentrations of power that define the current digital landscape. In this talk, I will explore the paradox of open and consider whether and under what conditions digital commons can provide a solution. I will discuss some strategies for reimagining openness to ensure its resilience and effectiveness in the face of evolving digital challenges.